Case joined JUC in 2011 with his wife Elizabeth and daughter Charlotte. They have welcomed two more kids since then, Everly and Ramona. Case and Elizabeth are both originally from Kansas and this is their first church home, though Case attended Christian-Science services on occasion growing up. Case is a lawyer, practicing as a partner at the firm Dorsey & Whitney, focusing on commercial litigation. He has been a volunteer firefighter in Golden since 2009. He and Elizabeth have been members of the Action Center Self-Sufficiency Society since 2012 and Elizabeth serves on their board. Case is also on the board of Project PAVE and active in local Democratic politics.